Skip to main content

Full text of "Methyl bromide fumigation of cottonseed in freight cars for the destruction of pink bollworms"

See other formats


1JBKAKI 


<*TATE  PLANT  BOARD 

June  1952 


E-838 


United  States  Department  of  Agriculture 

Agricultural  Research  Administration 

Bureau  of  Entomology  and  Plant  Quarantine 


METHYL  BROMIDE  FUMIGATION  OF  COTTONSEED  IN  FREIGHT  CARS 
FOR  THE  DESTRUCTION  OF  PINK  BOLLWORMS^ 

By  G.   L.    Phillips, 
Division  of  Stored  Product  Insect  Investigations 


From  1945  to  1951  experiments  were  carried  on  in  Texas  to  determine 
how  methyl  bromide  fumigation  could  be  utilized  in  the  treatment  of  cotton- 
seed originating  in  areas  quarantined  because  of  the  pink  bollworm,    to 
prevent  it  from  being  disseminated  through  transportation.     Heat  treat- 
ment had  long  been  the  standard  practice,    but  in  many  instances  fumiga- 
tion would  be  much  easier. 

Preliminary  tests  demonstrated  that  pink  bollworm  larvae  embedded 
in  cottonseed  were  killed  by  exposure  to  moderate  concentrations  of 
methyl  bromide.     In  1946  methyl  bromide  fumigation  of  sacked  cotton- 
seed intended  for  planting  purposes  was  approved  for  use  under    the  pink 
bollworm  quarantine  (BEPQ  558).     In  a  revision  of  this  quarantine  in  1948 
methyl  bromide  fumigation  of  bulk  cottonseed  in  large  steel  storage  tanks 
was  approved  for  use.     A  forced  circulation  system  was  provided  to 
distribute  the  gas  through  the  seed  mass  (Phillips  and  Bodenstein  1). 
The  development  of  a  method  for  fumigating  bulk  cottonseed  in  freight 
cars  or  trailer  vans  is  described  herein. 

Tests  on  freight-car  fumigation  were  carried  on  at  El  Paso  from 
1945  to  1949.     During  1949  and  1950  further  tests  were  made  near  San 
Antonio.     The  first  commercial  evaluation  tests  were  made  at  Lubbock. 

All  tests  were  made  with  carload  lots  of  bulk  cottonseed.     In  the  El 
Paso  area  no  cottonseed  was  moved  commercially  by  railway  freight; 
so  it  was  necessary  to  load  freight  cars  especially  for  the  tests,    and 
then  remove  the  seed  before  another  loading.     Cottonseed    and  unloading 


1/    The  following  members  of  the  Bureau  assisted:    J.   K.   Blocker, 
A.    L.    Broman,    J.   S.   Cook,    Roy  A.    Fischer,    A.   H.   Halverson,    G.   G. 
Harris,    P.   L.    Netterville,    R.    R.    Rost,     and   R.   S.    Van  Hoak.     The 
following  members  of  the  Texas  Department  of  Agriculture  also  assisted: 
C.   W.    Foster,   G.   C.   Harris,    and  Edgar  Jung.     Acknowledgement  is 
also  due  to  L.    F.   Curl,    director  of  the  Southwestern  Region  of  the  Bureau, 
for  his  constant  support  of  the  research  program. 


facilities  were  kindly  provided  by  the  Farmers  Cooperative  Oil  Mill  at 
El  Paso.     Tests  near  San  Antonio  were  performed  in  carloads  of  seed 
provided  by  the  Swift  and  Company  Oil  Mill. 

Because  of  the  large  amount  of  labor  needed  for  loading  and  unloading 
cars,    locating  samples,    and  cutting  thousands  of  individual  cotton  seeds 
to  determine  mortality  (samples  averaged  from  13  to  60  larvae  per  1,000 
seeds),    only  a  few  carloads  could  be  tested  in  one  season. 

Tests  without  Forced  Circulation 

Before  the  value  of  forced  circulation  was  demonstrated  by  fumigation 
in  steel  storage  tanks,    various  methods  were  used  to  apply  methyl  bromide 
in  efforts  to  attain  satisfactory  distribution  throughout  the  load  of  cotton- 
seed.    They  included  (1)  introduction  of  the  entire  methyl  bromide  dosage 
in  the  head  space  above  the  load;  (2)  injection  of  the  entire  dosage  into  the 
load;  (3)  introduction  of  half  above  the  head  and  injection  of  the  other  half; 
and  (4)  application  as  a  spray  (dissolved  in  carbon  tetrachloride)  to  the 
surface  of  the  load.     Innovations  were  tried,    such  as  partial  loads,    addi- 
tional sealing  of  floors  and  doorways  with  gas-proof  material,    circulation 
of  the  gas  above  the  load,    providing  risers  (vertical  tunnels)  through  the 
load  to  assist  penetration  of  dosage  applied  with  a  blast  of  carbon  dioxide, 
and  liberation  of  the  dosage  into  tunnels  through  the  load. 

In  most  tests    1/2 -pound  samples  of  infested  cottonseed  were  placed 
at  selected  locations  throughout  the  seed  mass.     In  some  tests  30  of  these 
samples  were  used,    in  others  24,    and  in  a  few  15.     Each  sample  contained 
from  1,200  to  1,500  seeds  and  from  25  to  100  larvae.     In  1948  a  procedure 
for  drawing  and  analyzing  gas  samples  was  put  into  use.     Thereafter  both 
seed  and  gas  samples  were  taken  to  determine  distribution. 

The  results  are  summarized  in  table  1.     In  only  two  tests  was  com- 
plete mortality  attained  in  all  samples,    and  repeated  tests  with  the  same 
procedure  gave  different  results. 

At  first  the  data  were  interpreted  to  mean  that  freight  cars  were  too 
leaky  to  serve  as  good  fumigation  chambers.     After  the  better  methods 
of  sealing  cars  had  been  developed,    it  became  evident  that  faulty  distri- 
bution of  the  gas  was  the  reason  for  areas  of  low  concentration. 


3- 


G 

o 

x: 

o 
g 

rG 

co 
rt 

tUD 

cd 

-a 


o 

JO     CD 
CD     CD 


g 
o 

•i-H 

CD 

a 

H-J 

u 

G 

•rH 

JO 

'C 

•r-l 

G 

G 

-rH 

co-  w 

•rH        CO 

T3     CD 
■ — i 

>->   G 

G      G 


CO 

u 

G 
O 

-G 


o 

<H-H 

co 


03    O 
CO    <M 

s 0 

'3   § 

o   cd 
o    & 

4J  •"" ' 

w 

0 

£  W 
cu 


J1 


03 

73 

«fH 

CD 

0 

01 

</) 

>i 

C 

Jh 

0 

(Tt 

H-> 

-H 

h 

o 

£ 

<H-H 

G 
CO 

o 

I 

en 

i 

+-> 

o 


T3 


40    o 


jG 

-m 

•r-l 

£ 

0) 
H-J 

>> 

+-> 

CO 

0) 

i— i 

a 

cd 

i — r 

a 

E 
o 
o 

•iH 
i— 1 

G 
+-> 
G 

G 
CD 
O 

G 

g' 

G 

O 

0) 

CO 

cd 

-rJ 

<H-H 

o 

co 
G 
O 


T3 
G 
O 

u 


cu 

tm 

G 

G 

O 

co 

o 

o 

73 

o 

o 

73 

•> 

G 

1—1 

rt 

Sh 

CD 

73 
O 

a 

■G 

CO 

H-> 

73 

CD 

C 

S 

G 

O 

a 

COCOCOOOOCOCOt>OCOCO 
mcOCOCOOCOCOLn^COCOCO 


I 
CD 


oo 

05 


cu 

CU 
73 


cd 


a 
cu 

CD 

73 


CD 


JO 
G 
O 

co 
G 

o 
o 
-a 

tT 

cu 

G 
CD 

> 
o 

o 

co 

G 
O 
O 


C3 


G 


m    3  *.P3 
CM"  fe  ~CO~  cm" 


o 


cd  n  co  n  o  ro  n 
t-  co   oo   r>   lO   CD   co 
i      i      i      i      i      i      i      i      i 
Loc^oo^r-c^-coco^ 


CO   o  o 

t>    t-  r- 

I       I  I 

oo 


O    CO 


COI^-I>C—    ^CDLOCOr-CDCDt> 


CM 


CD 


73 

a 
o 

— i 

cu 
> 
o 

JO 
05 

G 

•iH 

03 
G 

■rH 

73 
CU 
N 


G 
■ — i 
O 
> 


CO 
CO    CM    CM    CO 


CD 
CD 


JO 

G 
O 
XI 

CO 

G 

o 
o 

73 

T3 
CD 
Jh 
CU 

> 
o 
o 

co 

G 

o 
o 


^  ^  ^  -  73 
T3  ™  ^  (D  T3  <D 
G     °     °    ^     G 


G 


_       r-H  _ ,        CU  r-H        CU 

1 — !  ' — 'co  co 

.co    3    G  co    UJ 

CM"  fe  &-I 


O  -^- 

O    CO  |co| 


G    cu 

i — i 

O     G 

CO     cu 

CO 

I 
cu 


73 
G 

O 

i — i 

CU 

> 

o 

rQ 

G 

G 
O 


73 
G 
O 


JO 
G 
O 

73 

CO 

rH 
O 
O 

73 
xT 

CU 

G 

cu 
> 

o 
o 

X 

r- 
0 
0 


G 

rG 


CM 

CO 

I 

o 


73 
CD 
U 
CU 

> 

o 

o 

u 
o 
o 


T3 
G 
O 


'J] 
CD 

CO 


-a 

G 

o 


G 

En 


CM 

£> 

I 

CD 


G 

a 
o 

<H 

o 

TO 

c 
cu 

rG 

o 

G 
0 

G 
CU 

H-> 

G 
CD 

a 

H-J 

G 
co 

G 
CD 
CO 


T3  -a 

G     G 
O     O 


G     G 


G 

o 

H-J 

G 
X5 


CO 


>> 

G 

O 

H-1 

U 

a 

«*H 

CO 

■:-i 

+-> 

G 

co 

G 

G 

-a 

CD 

H-» 

G 

u 

•rH 

T3 

G 

•r-t 

CO 

•rH 

CO 

>> 

1 — 1 

G 

C 

. 

. 

G 

co 

CO 

i~> 

u, 

co 

G 

G 

G 

O 

O 

ojO 

rC 

.G 

^ 

co 

m 

CO 

"^ 

^ 

CD 

r— i 

-a 

T3 

a 

CD 

CD 

s 

CO 

CO 

G 

o 

O 

co 

a 

a 

X 

X 

o 

W  W  2 
-^l^lco"! 


4- 


p 

QJ 

o 

QJ 


ph 

o 


CO 

CO 

r- 

m  o 

o 

o 

o 

[> 

t> 

CD 

CO 

t— i 

c~  ^ 

1 

o 

o 

Oi 

m 

m 

Oi 

-t-> 

ojo 

c 

0) 

QJ 
• — i 

rQ 

o 

'OJO 

c 

•rH 
i-H 

QJ 

QJ 
> 

o 
.a 

i 

QJ 

p 

o 

T3 
QJ 

rH 

o 

<rH 

> 

TJ 

> 

CT3 

cd 

O 

P 

u-i 

1 

o 

above 
rom  tra 

lfl 

w 

f 

rQ 

xs 

rom  4 
iling 

O 

o 

in 

-t-> 

g 

o 

<4H 

QJ 

cd 

QJ 

g 

cd 

g 
o 
u 

O 
O 

g 

o 

Ih 

Vh 

a> 
o 

0) 

c 

a     rrH, 

T3     ^ 

T3 
QJ 

-a 

QJ 
+-> 
CJ 

T3 
TJ-" 

T3 
QJ 
h-> 

a 

•rH 

QJ 
OJO 

cd 

o 

3     ° 

QJ    3 

QJ 
> 

O 
o 

w 

u 
o 
o 

r— * 

•rH 

r— 1 

a 

QJ 

QJ 

■r-3 

QJ 

QJ 

C 

a.  oj 

a  9r 

a 

^ 

•l-l 

QJ 

•rH 

T3 

ray  a 
cent 

o" 

O* 

-a 

ray  ap 
pray  s 

cd 

>> 

cd 

a 

QJ 
QJ 

-a 

QJ 

he 
cd 

> 
O 
O 

Ih 

QJ 
CJO 

cd 

o 

<<H 

g 

o 

a  c 

a, 

, 

O 

O 

o 

Id 

CO      £ 

a  w 

t)-H 

w 

Vh 

T3 

O 

-— 

-a 

_c 

0 

o 

C/J 

«4H 

XI 

TD    "° 

.  -a? 

T3 

T3 

CO 

tS 

TJ 

73 

•a 

— 

cd    ,-. 
o    g 

load. 
1  loa 

g 

cd 
O 

QJ 

T3 

cd 

o 

cd 

o 

g 

o 

1 — 1 

cd 
o 

s 

cd 

o 

- 

•r-l 

— '    o 

o 

» 1 

13 

' — ' 

o 

rt 

1 — ' 

o 

1 — ' 

u 

r-.    o 

o 

,-H 

QJ 

i — i 

1 — 1 

o 

QJ 

i— i 

O 

—1 

P 

■3-° 

i — i 
^    p 

rQ 

3 

I/) 

CO 

r—t 

p 

rQ 

W 

i— i 

P 

£2 

•—* 

p 

- 

fe 

CO"  fc 

b 

CM" 

fe 

fe 

Ph 

03 

CO 

CM 

o 

OS 

T— 1 

CO 

a> 

00 

I 

1 

C- 

1 

t- 

CO 

o 

Oi    I> 

00 

m 

CO 

co 

00 

CO 

00 

t>    CO 

r- 

r> 

CO 

CO 

c 
o 
U 


QJ 
■ — i 

cd 
H 


QJ 

T3 

•rH 

rH 

O 

i— ) 

rC 

o 

cd 

fn 

H-> 

QJ 

H-J 

c 

O 

-a 

rQ 

cd 

rH 

o 

cd 

o 

tj-H 

«*H 

o 

o 

a 

• 

o 

. — 1 

-»-> 

cd 

bjD 

c 

o 

in 

CM 

-a 

• 

QJ 

H 

>^, 

cd 

C 

Sh 

r- 1 

a 

CO 

m 

CM 


in 


m 


QJ 

O 

QJ 

cd 

T3 

<«H 

•rH 

rH 

f-i 

P 

o 

co 

i-H 

rC 
O 

cd 

O 

u 

QJ 

H-J 

QJ 

rC 

-M 

c 

c 

O 

■r-l 

rO 

CO 

rH 

cd 

-a 

o 

cd 

<H-H 

o 

O    to 

o 

• 

-t-> 

•— t 

c 

a 

■rH 

bJO 

T3 

CM 

QJ 

H-> 

c 

a 

I-H 

QJ 

CO 


c 

QJ 

•rH 

1 

CO 

H-> 

CJ 

cd 
a 
in 

cd 

rQ 

rH 
•rH 

QJ 

cd 

H-> 
O 

c 

•rH 

QJ 

•1 — 3 

c 

•rH 

T3 
QJ 

C<-l 

cd 

cd 

QJ 

rC 

i — i 
QJ 

rH 

H-> 
■rH 

"a 

CO 

I 1 

cd 

s: 

T3 

C 

QJ 
OJD 

QJ 

QJ 

> 

cd 

> 

c 

I/) 

QJ 

ja 

o 

r^ 

rt 

CO 


Q 


-5- 


cu 


cj 


c 
cu 
u 

CU 
Ph 


CM 

05 


>l 


CM    CO 
CO    CO 


i_ 

-*-■     -J 

• 

Cd      g 

«*H 

^      *H 

i      w 

in    cd 

5   o 

cd  «»-i 

cu  g 

-O    ° 

C     CU 

CU    X 

-C 

cu  o 
bo  a 

u 

cd   cu 

O   Xi 

CO 

■h     cj 

5  S 
73   o 

w  m 

r-H         CU 

<H        (-1 

5   o 

o  <~ 

c 

c    • 

3    u, 

o  £ 

-t->    cu 

•r-t 

_    +-» 

f  o 

5   c 

2    CM 

£    cu 

O 

-|->    CJ 

a  x 

c 

..  +-> 

•*    rrt 

13    cd 

X     TO 

cd 

cd 

O  % 

O  « 

^    > 

r— 1       '""I 

•— <     CD 

I— t               -. 

^    -i 

r-j      ,-fl 

P 

P 

fr 

fe 

o  o 

X   XI 


o 


c 
o 

•1-1 

p 


01 


o 

o 
cd 

co 

•iH 

Cfl 

to 
C 

P 

X 

cu 

cd 
o 

•iH 

X 

c 

co 

•r-i 

(0 

>> 

r— I 

cd 
cd 

co 

cd 
tin 


•■H  -i-H 
X 

cu  a 

co  ■** 

cd  t-j 

£  o 

•z  X 

1  S 

o  « 

£  X 

-*-*  cd 

3  C    O 

a,-'-*  jo 

w  w    cd 


CU 


cu 


cd  r; 
to  3 
O    ' 


cu 
o 
cd 
a 

CO 


to 

cd 


X 

cu 

£ 

o 

1 — 1 

1 — 1 

a 

Zj 

X 

X 

■H 

cd 

X 

o 

1— 1 

c 

•I-l 

X 

o 

-M 

c 

c 

0 

•1-1 

~ 

X 

h 

cu 

cd 

-t-> 

o 

o 

'-_, 

CO 


o 


X 

CU 
X 

p 

I — I 
CJ 

c 

•1-1 
CO 

cu 

1—1 

a 
S 

cd 
to 

X 

cu 
cu 
to 

c 
o 

-M 

+-> 

o 
o 

o 

>l 


-  6  - 


Tests  with  Forced  Circulation 

The  satisfactory  distribution  of  methyl  bromide  in  large  steel  storage 
tanks  resulting  from  forced  circulation  prompted  attempts  to  utilize 
forced  circulation  in  freight-car  fumigation.     The  arrangement  in  the 
steel  tanks  permitted  a  fairly  even  flow  of  air,    or  gas,    through  the  cotton- 
seed from  top  to  bottom,  because  of  a  reduction  in  pressure  beneath  the 
load  as  air  was  withdrawn  from  beneath  the  false  floor,    and  an  addition 
of  pressure  above  the  load  as  the  air  was  returned  to  the  head  space  under 
considerable  velocity.     Since  it  was  not  feasible  to  place  a  raised  floor  in 
the  freight  car  and  thus  permit  an  even  reduction  over  the  entire  floor 
area,    air  was  removed  from  one  portion  of  this  area  by  means  of  ducts 
laid  on  the  car  floor. 

In  the  exploratory  tests  a  blower  was  placed  on  top  of  the  load  of 
cottonseed  to  suck  air  from  the  floor  level  through  perforated  hose 
buried  beneath  the  load.     This  arrangement  gave  fairly  satisfactory 
distribution,    for  all  pink  bollworm  larvae  were  killed  in  the  24  samples 
of  cottonseed  in  each  of  the  last  two  tests.     The  gas  samples  withdrawn 
in  two  successful  tests,    in  which  the  load  was  treated  with  6  and  8  pounds 
of  methyl  bromide  per  1,000  cubic  feet,    showed  the  following  concentrations, 
in  ounces  per  1,000  cubic  feet: 


Time 

6  pounds 

8  pounds 

30  minutes 

88  -12 

116  -     7 

3  hours 

50  -  12 

68-15 

6 

33  -  13 

56  -  19 

10 

33  -  iu 

40-16 

24 

17 

24-  16 

These  tests  show  that,    even  though  complete  mortality  was  obtained 
in  all  the  samples  of  cottonseed,    there  was  considerable  variation  in  gas 
ncentration   at  the  24  selected  points.     The  points  of  low  concentration 
were  not  associated  with  any  position  in  the  car,    although  they  occurred 
more  often  at  the  floor  level  than  in  the  body  of  the  load.     Further  tests 
with  improved  circulation  were  therefore  undertaken. 

Additional  tests  were  made  in  an  experimental  fumigation  chamber 
to  determine  the  minimum  lethal  concentration.     The  results  of  these 
tests  are  given  in  table  2. 


7  - 


O    cd 

u    , 

U 

lo    cu 

C    £2 

.2  a 

+j    cd 

G    -,- 

CU     O 

O     O 

C  <7 

o    ,', 

o   -3 

w  -9 

cd    3 

t>0  o 

£  o 

a  ^ 

£    cd 

co    C 

T3    '* 

O     a, 

CU     ^ 

a  g 

2  w 

2  c 

cd    cd 

>    bJO 

■r-t 

o    § 

<M   p 

T3    fc 

CD 

+-> 

{?.  10 

Oil  -t-» 

■•H      CO 

g     CU 

3    ** 

«"     t, 

cn  ?! 

S  V 

S-i    "P 

o  ^ 

is  .HP 

3  « 

*.S 

fe 

.5  +j< 
o.  5 

O 

O 

'    '    -H 

r- 

<*H        0 

o  a 

cu 

>->  ^ 

> 

0 

■H       0 

,D 

r— I       r 1 

cd 

a 

+j     0) 

to 

*-.     -P 

CU 

O    +J 

tn 

^,   o 

3 

1    -1-* 

+-> 

rrt 

1      a; 

,      r— I 

tn 

CO 

cu    J-, 

6 
cu 

p  S 

0)     H 

o  ,2 

en 

a>    o 

3 
o 

CU    Ch 

X! 

a    . 

"<* 

p 

CO       y 

CM 

U     JX 

o  2 

p  ° 

3   °, 

O     H 

0)    '-J 

o    ns 

7      -*-1 

fc      *- 

CO 

Ih 

P 

*3 

£_,         • 

o 

CU    Ch 

a    . 

o 

1—1 

p 

co    £ 

CU 

o  2 

p  ° 

3   °, 

O     r-T 

p  £ 

<u  'p. 

^         *H 

cu    o 

to 

P 

o 

fc  g 

cu  C« 

Xi 

a    . 

p 

to 

co   5 

cu 

o  ° 

p  ° 

p  ° 

0- 

p- 

CU    '-j 

cj    nS 

71    Jh 

o    o 

to 

^  fi 

• 

p 

ti       -M 

O 

cu  ^ 

-P 

a   P 

CO 

co    o 

?,  o 

c  ° 

3    ° 

o  - 

CO 

Jh     +S 

cu 

CU    Cm 

+-> 

^  ^J 

P 

p 

p 

CO     o 

•rH 

^  ^ 

B 

°  2 

% 

3    ° 
j   0   rn" 

ooooooooooo 
ooooooooooo 


r-OOCONt-NNCM^rHN 


o  to  -* 

O    Oi    CT) 


o  o  o  o  o  o  o 
o  o  o  o  o  o  o 


ooocoaiioio^mLn^ 


tomoiooHmcoNniM 
cococoffioofflojcoaicoco 


cMrHMcoco'tin^incom 


CMOOOCOCMLOlOD-OCD 
I>t>COCOCOI>Cv-I>t>CDtO 


nNCOtDOi^COCDNC-CD 


^■^^cooomtooococo 


-8  - 

From  these  tests  it  was  concluded  that  complete  mortality  of  pink 
bollworm  larvae  could  be  expected  if  the  concentration  could  be  kept 
above  10  ounces  per  1,000  cubic  feet  at  all  points  in  a  carload  of  seed 
for  the  first  10  hours. 

A  better  circulation  system  was  devised  which  utilized  a  portable 
blower  operated  outside  the  car.     A  4-inch  duct  made  of  downspouting  and 
perforated  with  1/4-inch  holes  on  three  sides  at  2 -inch  intervals,   but  with 
the  distal  end  closed,    was  laid  down  the  center  of  the  car  floor  from  end 
to  end  before  it  was  loaded  (fig.  1).     A  6 -inch  side  duct  led  from  the  center 
to  one  doorway.     This  doorway,    opposite  the  loading  door,    was  sealed  off 
with  a  paper  grain  doori^  properly  lapped  and  sealed  gastight,    and  the  side 
duct  was  inserted  through  the  paper  seal  (fig.  2).     The  ducts  were  then 
covered  by  the  load  of  seed.     A  portable  blower  (fig.  3)  with  a  gastight 
bearing  was  attached  by  6 -inch  flexible  tubing  to  the  duct  protruding  through 
the  paper  seal  (fig.  4).       The  discharge  of  the  blower  was  returned  to  the 
head  space  above  the  load  by  another  length  of  flexible  tubing  attached  to 
a  metal  collar  inserted  at  the  top  of  the  paper  seal.     A  blower  driven  by 
a  2 -horsepower  motor  was  used.     The  fumigant  was  applied  as  a  gas  in 
the  discharge  duct  of  the  blower  where  it  was  carried  to  the  head  space 
above  the  load  and  drawn  down  through  the  seed. 

A  series  of  six  tests  were  made  with  this  circulation  system,    with  a 
dosage  schedule  of  6  pounds  per  1,000  cubic  feet  for  24  hours.     The  blower 
was  operated  for  only  about  10  minutes  after  the  fumigant  was  applied. 
The  ranges  of  concentration  obtained  are  shown  in  table  3.     Even  though 
the  concentration  at  certain  sampling  points  dropped  below  10  ounces  at 
ine  10 -hour  period,    it  was  far  above  that  amount  after  3  hours.     The  fact 
that  these  concentrations  were  above  the  minimum  lethal  amount  was 
substantiated  by  the  fact  that  all  larvae  in  the  cottonseed  samples  were 
killed. 

Table  3.  --Range  of  concentration  of  methyl  bromide  after  forced-circula- 
tion fumigation  of  freight  carloads  of  cottonseed. 


Number  of 

Ounces  per  1,000  cubic  feet  after- - 

samples 

30  minutes 

3  hours 

10  hours 

24  hours 

21 

16  -    43 

14-    39 

7-21 

4-9 

22 

27-  116 

15  -  112 

8-33 

6-14 

22 

20  -  114 

18  -  116 

7-24 

6  -  11 

21 

37-    84 

16  -    35 

11-27 

9-16 

22 

53-    93 

30  -    53 

14-  27 

7-26 

21 

17-  110 

16  -    69 

8-21 

6-13 

2/    The  use  of  the  paper  grain  door  was  suggested  by  J.    K.   Blocker 
and  W.    F.   Sennette,    Division  of  Pink  Bollworm  Control. 


9  - 


Application  of  Treatment  for  Quarantine  Purposes 

On  the  basis  of  these  tests,    fumigation  of  cottonseed  in  freight  cars, 
using  a  forced-circulation  system  similar  to  that  used  in  the  experiment, 
was  authorized  for  quarantine  purposes  in  February  1950.     As  a  safety 
factor  the  dosage  was  set  at  7  pounds  per  1,000  cubic  feet  when  the  bulk- 
cottonseed  temperature  averaged  60°  F.    or  above.     Use  of  the  method 
was  limited  to  certain  regulated  areas  with  very  light  infestation  where 
adequate  heat-treatment  equipment  was  not  available.     By  arrangement 
any  commercial  use  was  to  be  supervised  by  the  writer  for  the  first 
season,    in  order  that  improvements  desirable  for  operation  under 
practical  conditions  might  be  introduced. 

The  Southland  Cotton  Oil  Company  used  this  method  on  approximately 
12,000  tons  of  cottonseed  to  be  shipped  by  rail  from  Lubbock,    Tex.     A 
total  of  306  cars  were  fumigated  in  this  operation. 

The  same  fumigation  procedure  was  used  for  all  cars.     Only  steel 
freight  cars  in  good  condition  were  used,    each  one  being  inspected  and 
approved.     Before  being  loaded,    the  floor  of  each  car  was  covered  with 
sisal-kraft  paper,    which  is  gasproof,    and  the  perforated  floor  duct  was 
put  in  place.     The  rear  doorway  (opposite  the  loading  door)  was  sealed 
with  a  paper  grain  door,    and  collars  were  inserted  for  the  attachment 
of  the  flexible  tubing  leading  to  and  from  the  portable  blower.     Wooden 
grain  doors  were  placed  in  the  loading  door  to  the  height  of  the  load. 
The  seed  was  transferred  from  a  trackside  warehouse  or  from  trucks 
by  a  seed  pump  (fig.  5),    in  which  the  cottonseed  is  sucked  up  by  a  powerful 
blower  and  blown  through  ducts  into  the  car.     The  top  of  the  load  was 
leveled  off  to  give  at  least  a  2-foot  head  space. 

When  the  loading  was  completed,    the  loading  door  was  sealed  in  part 
with  a  paste  made  of  asbestos  cement  and  oil  and  in  part  with  scotch 
masking  tape.     The  flexible  blower  ducts  were  attached  to  the  collars 
in  the  paper  grain  door.     The  blower,    which  was  driven  by  a  5-horsepower 
gasoline  engine,    was  started,    and  the  dosage  of  methyl  bromide  admitted 
to  the  exhaust  duct  after  being  volatilized  by  passing  through  a  coil 
immersed  in  very  hot  water.     The  blower  was  operated  for  approximately 
2  minutes  after  the  gas  was  introduced  and  then  detached.     The  collars 
in  the  paper  grain  door  were  removed  and  the  holes  quickly  sealed  with 
gasproof  paper  and  masking  tape.     The  car  door  was  then  closed  and  the 
fumigation  allowed  to  proceed  for  24  hours  without  further  attention. 
The  blower  unit  was  moved  to  the  next  car  to  be  fumigated. 

As  many  as  16  cars  were  fumigated  in  one  day,    the  limiting  factor 
being  the  speed  of  loading.     One  portable  blower  unit  was  considered 
capable  of  handling  20  cars  per  day. 


-  10  - 

The  actual  fumigation  procedure  was  handled  by  representatives  of 
the  oil-mill  company.—'    The  certification  of  the  cottonseed  was  handled 
by  regular  inspectors  of  the  Bureau  of  Entomology  and  Plant  Quarantined 

The  method  developed  for  testing  the  efficiency  of  gas  distribution  in 
large  steel  tanks,    whereby  two  gas  samples  were  withdrawn  from  a 
selected  sampling  point  at  any  time  during  the  fumigation  period,    and  the 
results  of  analysis  compared  with  a  standard  curve  (Phillips  and  Latta  2), 
was  adopted  as  a  means  of  observing  the  effectiveness  of  the  freight-car 
fumigation  at  Lubbock. 

The  lowest  concentration  of  gas  was  found  to  be  at  a  point  near  the 
floor  about  half  way  between  the  car  wall  and  the  center  duct  and  about 
one-third  the  distance  from  the  end  wall  to  the  doorway.     This  was 
designated  as  the  standard  sampling  point.     A  curve  was  plotted  based 
on  the  average  of  the  concentrations  present  at  this  point  in  tests. 
The  lowest  concentration  present  at  this  position  in  the  experimental 
cars  which  was  associated  with  complete  mortality  in  biological  samples 
was  considered  as  the  maximum  deviation  from  the  average. 

A  sample  was  withdrawn  from  a  car  under  fumigation  by  inserting 
a  sampling  probe  through  the  paper  grain  door  near  the  floor  level  along 
a  line  between  the  center  of  the  doorway  and  one  of  the  opposite  corners. 
By  inserting  the  probe  14-1/2  feet  at  this  angle  the  standard  sampling 
point  was  reached  consistently  with  accuracy.     The  analysis  of  this 
sample  was  matched  against  the  curve  to  indicate  the  efficiency  of 
distribution  in  each  car  sampled. 

It  was  not  possible  to  sample  all  cars  fumigated,    but  an  attempt  was 
made  to  sample  at  least  half  of  those  fumigated  each  day.     Analyses 
were  made  on  samples  from  162  of  the  306  cars  fumigated,    and  only 
one  fell  below  the  maximum  allowable  deviation.     This  car  was  re- 
fumigated. 

The  samples  were  withdrawn  when  convenient,    so  that  the  time  of 
sampling  ranged  from  30  minutes  to  17  hours  after  the  start  of  the 
exposure.     These  concentrations  at  the  sampling  points  were  grouped 
according  to  1-hour  intervals,    i.e.,    those  between  0.5  and  1.4  hours, 
1.5  and  2.4  hours,    etc.,    and  an  average  was  taken  for  each  interval. 
These  data  were  compared  with  the  concentrations  found  in  the  seed 
mass  in  large  steel  tanks  under  fumigation  and  with  the  concentration 
found  at  the  standard  sampling  point  in  the  experimental  fumigations 
as  shown  in  figure  6. 


3/   J.    R.    Richardson  and  Frank  P.   Dickson. 

4/   Certification  was  supervised  by  H.    L.    Alford,    M.    E.   Currie,    and 
G.    W.   Chowns,    and  performed  by  Inspectors  T.  P.    Patterson,    R.J. 
Morits,    E.    L.   Wilde,    E.   I.    Fosmire,    R.    K.    Robinson,    A.   S.    Pela,    and 
Ike  Laird  of  the  Division  of  Pink  Bollworm  Control.     They  also  assisted 
the  research  staff  in  many  ways  as  their  duties  permitted. 


- 11  - 

The  fumigation  of  306  carloads  of  cottonseed  with  only  one  rejection 
and  the  satisfactory  concentration  patterns  found  in  the  sampled  cars 
were  considered  ample  proof  of  the  practicability  of  freight-car  fumiga- 
tion with  the  apparatus  developed  for  forced  circulation.     Therefore,    in 
July  1950,    the  quarantine  regulations  in  BEPQ  558  were  further  modified 
to  authorize  freight-car  fumigation  in  lieu  of  heat  treatment  in  all  lightly 
infested  areas  in  Texas,   New  Mexico,    and  Oklahoma,    and  as  an  additional 
treatment  for  cottonseed  moving  from  heavily  infested  areas. 

Summary 

Methyl  bromide  fumigation  was  authorized  for  the  treatment  of  sacked 
cottonseed  in  1946,    and  for  bulk  cottonseed  in  large  steel  storage  tanks 
fitted  with  means  for  forced  circulation  in  1948.     A  method  for  fumigating 
bulk  cottonseed  in  freight  cars,    developed  between  1945  and  1951,    is 
described  in  this  paper. 

Efforts  were  made  to  attain  a  satisfactory  distribution  of  methyl 
bromide  throughout  a  freight-car  load  of  cottonseed  by  various  methods 
of  application,    such  as  applying  it  in  the  head  space  above  the  load, 
injecting  it  into  the  load,    applying  half  the  dosage  above  and  injecting 
half,    and  dissolving  in  carbon  tetrachloride  and  spraying  on  the  surface. 
None  were  successful.     Other  innovations,    such  as  partial  loads,    additional 
sealing  of  floors  and  doorways  with  gas  proof  material,    providing  risers 
(vertical  and  horizontal  tunnels)  through  the  load  to  assist  in  penetration, 
and  following  the  application  with  a  blast  of  carbon  dioxide,    were  also 
unsuccessful. 

Attempts  were  then  made  to  adapt  the  method  of  forced  circulation 
used  in  fumigation  of  cottonseed  in  large  steel  storage  tanks.     A  gas- 
distribution  pattern  was  obtained  that  provided  a  lethal  concentration  at 
all  sampling  points.     In  the  method  finally  adopted  a  portable  blower 
operated  outside  the  freight  car  pulls  air  from  beneath  the  load  through 
a  specially  designed  duct  system  and  returns  it  to  the  space  above  the 
load.     The  blower  is  run  during  gas  volatilization  and  for  2  to  10  minutes 
thereafter,    then  disconnected,    the  car  sealed,    and  the  blower  moved  to 
the  next  car  to  be  fumigated. 

This  method  for  treating  cottonseed  was  authorized  for  use  on  quar- 
antined cottonseed  in  February  1950  in  a  limited  area  under  supervision. 
The  dosage  schedule  is  7  pounds  per  1,000  cubic  feet  for  24  hours  expo- 
sure at  60°  F.   or  above,    and  8  pounds  at  lower  temperatures. 

The  first  trial  on  a  commercial  basis  was  at  Lubbock,    Tex.,  where 
approximately  12,000  tons  of  cottonseed  in  306  freight  cars  were 
fumigated.     All  but  one  of  the  162  cars  that  were  checked  by  gas  analyses 
were  found  to  have  the  required  gas  concentration. 

In  July  1950  the  forced-circulation  method  was  authorized  as  an 
alternate  method  for  treating  cottonseed  for  the  destruction  of  pink  boll- 
worm  larvae. 


-12- 


Literature  Cited 

(1)  Phillips,    G.   L.,    and  W.   G.  Bodenstein 

1948.  A  successful  large-scale  experiment  in  methyl  bromide 

fumigation  of  bulk  cottonseed  for  pink  bollworm  control. 
Jour.   Econ.   Ent.   41:  804-805. 

(2)  Phillips,    G.   L.,    and  Randall  Latta 

1949.  Current  use  of  methyl  bromide  for  the  fumigation  of  cotton- 

seed.    Down  to  Earth  (Dow  Chemical  Co.)  5(1):  11-13. 


13  - 


o 

c 

o 

■iH 

-t-> 

\k  • 

3 
O 
Q. 

M 

C 
* 

o 
•a 

V 

p 

-t-> 

c 
o 
o 

-t-> 
T3 

c 

X 

cd 

ft. 

o 
o 

to 

J      2 

K-        2        -1 

u 
a) 

o 

a 

c 

^  : 

0 

o 

','     + 

v_i__j/ 

o 

ft. 

i 

o 

0> 

c 

O 

i 

L 

o 
o 

■o 

■o 

"5» 

1— 1 

1      ° 

o 

CO 

c 

0) 

1 

£ 

X 

1 

-t-> 

c 

t_ 

UJ 

o 

J 

u 

J 

CJ 

o 

c           V 

»■-►  i 

— ► 

CM 

I-1 

-a 

■o 

:    1 

X! 

4)                  r" 

+-> 

4- 

J 

«^h 

O 

o 

ft. 

O 

«♦- 
ft. 

• 

; 

c 
£ 

ft.    o. 

a; 
u 

o     o 

ft. 
o 
o 

a) 

i — i 
a 

^    o 

o 

s 

5         >* 

c 

*-«>-> 

+j 

o           ' 

ft. 

"5 

ft. 
C5 

1^— «->— ■•-•-w •_ J 

£  .2 

o 
Q. 

V 

ft. 
4> 
Q. 

a 

1 

O    W 

£  c 

e  * 

»^ 

Q_ 

CO  ^ 

o 

Sh     CD 

ft. 

bn-o 

* 

i 

?? 

o 

!J 

M 

•.. 

r— 1       QJ 

CO 

0 

S 

M 

0   •+-> 

•r-l     ^ 

14  - 


Figure  2.  --Car  loaded  ready  for  fumigation, 
showing  collars  inserted  at  top  and  bottom 
of  grain  door. 


Figure  3.  --Gasoline  engine  mounted  to  drive 
circulating  blower.     The  volatilizer  unit  and 
the  scales  for  weighing  dosage  are  also 
shown. 


-  15 


Figure  4.  --Volatilizer  and  circulating  unit 
attached  to  one  of  several  loaded  cars  ready 
for  fumigation.     The  unit  could  handle  one 
car  in  15  to  18  minutes. 


Figure  5.  --Portable  seed  blower  transferring 
cottonseed  from  a  truck  to  a  freight  car. 


-  16 


UNIVERSITY  OF  FLORIDA 

111  urn  iiii  in  mi  in  inn  ill  Ml  il 


3  1262  09239  6448 


50 


H40 

UJ 
UJ 

u_ 
o 

CD30 

z> 
o 

o 
o 
o 


20 


tr 

UJ 

a 
(/) 

UJ 

o 

3 
O 


10 


Commercial  freight-car  fumigations 


Experimental  freight-car  fumigations 


Steel-tank  fumigations 


8  12  16 

TIME-HOURS 


20 


24 


Figure  6.  --Methyl  bromide  concentrations  at  standard  sampling  points  in  com- 
mercial and  experimental  freight-car  fumigations  as  compared  with  steel- 
tank  fumigations.